Pride in Parenting: Training Curriculum for Lay Home Visitors
Linda T. Diamond, M.S. and Marion H. Jarrett, Ed.D., editors.

Unit 7
Cultural Diversity/Ethnicity Among Families

The District of Columbia has a significant amount of diversity in its population. Increasing awareness of how cultural diversity can influence families and parenting is important in the understanding of different people. Having this awareness is vital to providing intervention that is culturally sensitive to the clients being served.

Objectives

By the end of this unit, participants will be able to:

  • Define 'Culture' and 'Ethnicity'.
  • Discuss how cultural diversity can influence families and parenting.
  • Describe ways in which they can become more culturally sensitive.
  • List several cultural myths and discuss information needed to dispel these.
  • Demonstrate several strategies for culturally sensitive intervention.

Time

3 Hours

Outline

A. Overview of Culture and Ethnicity
B. Examples of How Culture and Ethnicity Impact the Families that the PSS will be Visiting
C. Summary and Review

Materials

  • Friedman, M. (1986). Family Nursing: Theory and Assessment. Connecticut: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
  • Holin, A. (1994). Cultural Sensitivity and the African-American Family. (unpublished paper).
  • Kavanagh & Kennedy (1992). Promoting Cultural Diversity. Newbury Park: Sage.
  • Leahey, M. & Wright, L. (1987). Families and Life Threatening Illness. Pennsylvania: Springer.
  • Leahey & Wright (1987). Families and Chronic Illness. Pennsylvania: Springer.
  • Leahey & Wright (1987). Families and Psychosocial Problems. Pennsylvania, Springer.
  • Lynch, E. & Hanson, M. (1992). Developing Cross-Cultural Competence: A Guide for Working with Young Children and Their Families. Baltimore, MD: Paul Brooks Publishing Co.
  • Hoflin (1994). A Cultural Journey. (Handout #1)
  • Myths for Discussion (Handout #2)
  • Flip Chart
  • Role Play Feedback (Overhead #1)
  • Post-Unit Evaluation
  • Post-Unit Test
  • Video Equipment: video camera, tripod, tape, VCR, and television
Advance Preparation

  • Review above references.
  • Make sufficient copies of handouts.
  • Try out video equipment. Set up camera to videotape role plays.



A. OVERVIEW OF CULTURE AND ETHNICITY

Rationale:

The PSS will likely come in contact with families whose culture and ethnicity is different from their own. In order to provide appropriate intervention, the PSS will have to be knowledgeable about the many aspects of the prevailing culture as well as about individual family differences.

Procedure:

1. Definitions of Culture and Ethnicity

Ask the participants to tell what culture and ethnicity mean to them.

Be sure to include the following information in your discussion.

  • Culture: the shared values, beliefs, behaviors, ideas, practices of a group of people, symbols (ie.clothing, language, decorations).
  • Multi-cultural: several different cultures or sub-cultures.
  • Cross-cultural/trans-cultural: learning to deal or bridge the gaps across several different cultures.

As an analogy, multi-cultural is like children engaged in parallel play in which there are several different non-interactive activities going on. Cross-cultural is where many children are playing a game in which there is communication and interaction.

Ethnicity: common racial make-up, some similar biological/genetic background, common geographical origin of people, who often share the same culture.

  • Recognize that the USA has the largest ethnic diversity of any major country:
  • The African-Americans are the largest ethnic group.
  • Latinos are the second largest ethnic group in the USA.

2. Understanding How Culture and Ethnicity Influence Families

During the discussion, try to elicit the following information from the group:

  • The core concept of ethnicity is that there is a common culture.
  • Ethnic groups often have shared ideas about:
  • kinship patterns
  • religious affiliation
  • language
  • nationality
  • physical features and appearances

Therefore families of certain ethnic groups often have similar idea and practices related to:

  • health
  • sickness
  • parenting
  • childrearing practices
  • child discipline
  • male-female relationships

3. Culture Shock

Discuss with participants what 'culture shock' means to them and how it might impact them. Be sure to include the following information in the discussion:

This occurs when an individual has a series of encounters where personal values, attitudes, beliefs and behaviors are challenged by another person's values, attitudes, beliefs and behaviors. These encounters usually disturb the balance of the individual (Hoflin, 1994).

There is a discomfort in relating to another culture. This discomfort is usually related to not understanding the culture of another group or person.

The PSS may experience the following feelings as they work with their families:

  • First enthusiasm, high spirits as you begin to work with the families.
  • Next you may find that your problem-solving or help strategies do not work with the families.
  • You may find that you disapprove or do not understand the habits or behaviors of the families you are working with, especially if they are different from yours.
  • You may realize that your education and background are different from the families and that makes it hard for you to understand the families.

4. Practical Suggestions and Advice for the PSS

Generate ideas from participants about what they can do to be more culturally sensitive. Use a flip chart to record ideas. Include the following in your list:

It will be important to understand the culture, the behavior, habits, knowledge and beliefs of the families.

Consult with colleagues and others who have experience with the families.

You can increase your awareness, sensitivity and appreciation of the culture of the families by:

  • Gathering as much information about the culture as possible.
  • Identifying lay people who can serve as cultural guides or mentors.
  • Finding ways to build trust with the members of the families.
  • Trying in a personal way, to experience the culture, learn about the holidays, foods, celebrate or get involved with community activities.
  • Learning the language and slang of the culture.

DO NOT MAKE ASSUMPTIONS ABOUT ALL MEMBERS OF THE CULTURAL GROUP BASED ON WHAT YOU LEARN FROM THE PERSONAL EXPERIENCES OF A FEW MEMBERS

Sometimes you may have to be sensitive to other family needs and feelings before you can address the purpose or planned intervention for the home visit.

You may need to earn the trust of the families. You can do this by being sensitive to their needs, concerns and beliefs. Your style of interaction should include warm, empathetic listening and verbalizations. You want to exhibit caring and understanding.

Have the group engage in the following exercises:

Practical Exercise #1 (30 MINUTES)

  1. Have PSS sit in groups. Ask them to talk about people they know of different ethnic backgrounds and the practices that they know about related to these families which are different and/or similar from their own family practices.
  2. Were they surprised by the practices?
  3. What do they think about the similarities?
  4. What do they think about the differences?
  5. Do the PSS believe these similarities or differences will effect how they might give care to such a family? In what ways could this happen?

Practical Exercise #2 (30 MINUTES)

  1. Have the PSS pair up(P1 and P2).
  2. Ask one to tell their partner about a negative situation that happened to them related to their ethnicity. Tell how she felt and what she did.
  3. Ask the partner P2 to think about what she might tell the P1 about how to make the situation more positive and/or help her handle a similar situation in the future.
  4. Role play these situations in the group. Focus on the feelings and behaviors of the P1 and P2.
 



B. EXAMPLES OF HOW CULTURE AND ETHNICITY IMPACT THE FAMILIES THAT THE PSS WILL BE VISITING

Rationale:

There are many myths about culture and minority status. The PS must be aware of these and learn how to dispel them. At the same time, it is also important to understand the basic facets of the African-American culture in order to deal sensitively with families.

Procedure:

Present the following information:

Many of the families that the PSS will be visiting will be African-American.

  • In African-American families, the extended family is often intact and provides significant support for new mothers and infants. So, when possible and agreed to by the new mom, they should be involved in the interventions for the family.
  • In African-American families, it is important to recognize the role and influence of the older woman, i.e., grandmothers, or mother of teen mother. Again, they may be gatekeepers for the family's health habits and practices and should be involved in the intervention if agreed to by the new mom.
  • Many African-Americans rely on themselves or friends to care for them when they are sick.
  • Many African-American families do not trust health care workers - it is possible that they may not trust you at first. Because they don't trust, they may not come to a doctor or clinic until they can no longer care for themselves. Sometimes they may not do exactly what the nurse or doctor tells them because of fear or mistrust. THIS IS WHERE THE PSS CAN BE VERY HELPFUL TO THE FAMILY BY EMPHASIZING THE IMPORTANCE OF HEALTH CARE.
  • African-American families in general value and love their children although they may be strict with them.
  • Family ties and kin are very important to African-American families.
  • BUT YOU MUST ALWAYS REMEMBER THAT NOT EVERY FAMILY IN AN ETHNIC GROUP IS ALIKE.

Practical Exercise #3 (30 minutes)

MYTHS FOR DISCUSSION (Source: Kavanagh & Kennedy, 1992). HANDOUT #2

  1. It is a myth that educated and professional individuals do not have minority status problems or involve themselves in such issues.
  2. It is a myth that personal concern with social stratification issues implies immaturity and non-professionalism.
  3. It is a myth that institutions must adapt to the needs of minority groups or individuals, rather than minorities adapting to social institutions.
  4. It is a myth that you can "get the feel" or "sense" of another culture without having to learn about its social organizations and social processes.
  5. It is a myth that health care providers cannot be reasonably prepared to handle cross-cultural and other situations involving diversity because health care personnel in the United States deal with people from more than 100 ethnic, racial, and cultural groups.
    • Have PSS read myths.
    • Lead a discussion with the PSS about their reactions to the myths.
    • Be sure to use the following materials as a guide for the discussion.

POINTS TO EMPHASIZE DURING THE DISCUSSION:

MYTH #1

  1. Regardless of educational or professional background or experience, workers of ethnic/minority groups deal with the same issues and prejudices of all members of that group.

MYTH #2

  1. Stereotypes still persist related to one's ability to do a job according to: SEX, RACE, ETHNICITY, AGE.
  2. It is a mistake to believe that social stratification issues are not relevant for all workers.
  3. Even employment situations are stratified and inequitable.

MYTH #3

  1. Most health care agencies and providers expect clients to adapt to the system.
  2. Health care systems are based upon routines to increase efficiency.
  3. Argument is that individualized care takes time and costs money.

MYTH #4

  1. People do need to be sensitive and aware of cultural groups.
  2. People need to be knowledgeable about patterns among groups of people...this gives/helps to empower health care providers to make valuable interventions.

MYTH #5

  1. Complete knowledge of a culture is not the goal.
  2. General knowledge about cultural patterns and social organizations is helpful to know what questions to ask...to gather information needed to provide interventions for families.

 



C. Summary and Review

Procedure:

1. Rephrase the objectives of this unit into questions. Have participants respond.

2. Review the following as the last statement for this unit:

RESPECTING OUR DIFFERENCES - 'What's in it for you?'

  • The more tolerant you are, the more open you are to learning about others.
  • The more you learn, the less you fear.
  • The less you fear, the more comfortable you will feel in all types of situations, with all kinds of people.
  • The more you get along with other people, the more successful you are ... and the more interesting your life becomes.
3. Distribute Post-Unit Evaluation.

4. Distribute Post-Unit Test

5. Distribute 'A Cultural Journey' for use as individuals decide. Encourage the participants to complete this activity.


Unit 7 Handout #1

A CULTURAL JOURNEY

Adapted from Developing Cross-Cultural Competence: A Guide for Working with Young Children and Their Families (eds.) Eleanor W. Lynch & Marci J. Hanson, (1992) Baltimore: Paul Brooks Publishing Co.

ORIGINS

  1. When you think about your roots, what country(ies) other than the United States do you identify as a place of origin for you or your family?
  2. Have you ever heard any stories about how your family or your ancestors came to the United States? Briefly, what was the story?
  3. Are there any foods that you or someone else prepares that are traditional for your country(ies) of origin? What are they?
  4. Are there any celebrations, ceremonies, rituals, holidays that your family continues to celebrate that reflect your country(ies) of origin? What are they? How are they celebrated?
  5. Do you or anyone in your family speak a language other than English because of your origins? If so, what language?
  6. Can you think of one piece of advice that has been handed down through your family that reflects the values held by your ancestors in the country(ies) of origin? What is it?


Unit 7 Handout #2

BELIEFS, BIASES, AND BEHAVIORS

  1. Have you ever heard anyone make a negative comment about people from your country(ies) of origin? If so, what was it?
  2. As you were growing up, do you remember discovering that your family did anything differently from other families that you were exposed to because of your culture, religion, or ethnicity? Name something that you remember that was different.
  3. Have you ever been with someone in a work situation who did something because of his or her culture, religion, or ethnicity that seemed unusual to you? What was it? Why did it seem unusual?
  4. Have you ever felt shocked, upset, or appalled by something that you saw when you were traveling in another part of the world? If so, what was it? How did it make you feel? Pick some descriptive words to explain your feelings. How did you react? In retrospect, how do you wish you would have reacted?
  5. Have you ever done anything that you think was culturally inappropriate when you have been in another country or with someone from a different culture? In other words, have you ever done something that you think might have been upsetting or embarrassing to another person? What was it? What did you do to try to improve the situation?

IMAGINE

  1. If you could be from another culture or ethnic group, what culture would it be? Why?
  2. What is one value from that culture or ethnic group that attracts you?
  3. Is there anything about that culture or ethnic group that concerns or frightens you? What is it?
  4. Name one concrete way in which you think your life would be different if you were from that culture or ethnic group.

MYTHS FOR DISCUSSION (Source: Kavanagh & Kennedy, 1992).

  1. It is a myth that educated and professional individuals do not have minority status problems or involve themselves in such issues.
  2. It is a myth that personal concern with social stratification issues implies immaturity and non-professionalism.
  3. It is a myth that institutions must adapt to the needs of minority groups or individuals, rather than minorities adapting to social institutions.
  4. It is a myth that you can "get the feel" or "sense" of another culture without having to learn about its social organizations and social processes.
  5. It is a myth that health care providers cannot be reasonably prepared to handle cross-cultural and other situations involving diversity because health care personnel in the United States deal with people from more than 100 ethnic, racial, and cultural groups.



Unit 7 Overhead #1

Role Play Feedback

  1. What do you think you the Parenting Support Specialist did well?
  2. What could the Parenting Support Specialist have changed or done differently?
  3. What other things do you think the Parenting Support Specialist might say or do to help a mother in this situation?



Unit 7 Post-Unit Evaluation

Post-Unit Evaluation

Unit Covered:_____

Date: _____

  1. Do you feel we covered all the information in this unit that we said we were going to?
  2. What did you like best about the unit?
  3. What did you like least about the unit?
  4. Was the information in this unit presented clearly? If not, please explain.
  5. In which skill areas do you feel you need more practice or help?
  6. How can we make this unit better?
  7. Any additional comments?



UNIT 7 Unit Test

CULTURAL DIVERSITY/ETHNICITY AMONG FAMILIES

UNIT TEST (10 POINTS)

I. TERMS (6 POINTS)
Match the terms with the correct meanings.

Culture
  Aunts, uncles, kin
Ethnicity
  Personal beliefs, values different from another person
Culture Shock
  Family born into or adopted into
Extended Family
  Shared beliefs, values, behaviors
Family of Origin
  An ethnic group
Hispanic American
  Race, or common geographic origin of group or people

II. LIST AT LEAST 4 STRATEGIES THE PSS CAN USE WHEN WORKING WITH ETHNICALLY DIVERSE FAMILIES (4 POINTS)

Previous Page

Table of Contents

Next Page

View Description for this Item

Search CLAS Materials Return to CLAS Home Page

About Us/Sobre | CLAS Publications/Publicaciones | Materials/Materiales
Links/Conexiones | Sitemap/Mapa | Home/Página Principal